When you click through from our site to a retailer and buy a product, we may earn affiliate commissions. This helps support our work, but does not affect what we cover or how, and it does not affect the price you pay.
It’s the festive time when everybody in NYC starts vibing with nature changing its color, and look out for pumpkin picking. And this article is all about the same thing, pumpkin picking Long Island.
Here you’ll find mention of both the regular pumpkin picking on Long Island farms and the U-picking from the vines. It really depends on what kind of fun you want to have and the experience you want to gather.
Places to Go Pumpkin Picking Long Island
1. Crossroads Farm at Grossman’s
Crossroads Farm at Grossman’s is a really good place for Pumpkin picking Long Island in the quiet surroundings of Nassau County. Their Farm is amazing, and you have to check it out!
Crossroads Farm at Grossman’s is the closest Organic farm near New York City that sells their fresh produce and honey (which is so pure, they sell it straight from the beehives) on their estate.
If you want to have a proper pumpkin picking long Island experience with all those hayrides, big size fields, this isn’t for you because this is such a tiny little, slow-paced space, and however, trust me, it feels a lot better to be here!
You’ll feel relaxed and chill here like it’s your own farm, and you’re working in it. You can do everything peacefully, like picking up your pumpkins, take them home and carve them maybe or do whatever you want! You can stay connected to the Facebook page of Crossroads Farm at Grossman’s for the latest updates.
Crossroads Farm at Grossman’s is situated at 480 Hempstead Avenue, Malvern, New York City 11565.
2. Water Drinker Farm
Just to let you know, that the Water Drinker Farm isn’t a good choice just for your Pumpkin Picking Long Island activity, but they’ve got some of the crazy and beautiful sunflower fields in the long Island, which definitely sets them apart from others.
And henceforth, they certainly deserve a place in the list.
You can do your regular pumpkin picking on Long Island (again, not from the vines!), enjoy hayrides, farm animals, corn mazes, and a lot more.
You’ll find their staff pretty supportive, and they offer services worth all your money.
You can check out the latest announcements regarding Pumpkin Picking Long Island in the Water Drinker Farm on their Facebook page.
The Water Drinker Farm is located at 663 Wading River Rd, Manorville, New York City, 11949.
3. Harbes Family Farm
Harbes Family Farm is really family-friendly with their services of barnyard animals, corn maze, and playground for the children. This is really a place you can take your kids to, and they won’t trouble you at all while you enjoy Pumpkin Picking Long Island.
They are a perfect choice if you want a day out trip for Pumpkin picking Long Island on the eastern side. You can enjoy farming activities all year along here.
Apart from the pumpkin farm, of course, they have a vineyard, which means you can even take your date here! Sip on their apple ciders and other drinks, along with apple cider donuts and roasted sweet corn sounds so delicious to me!
Guess what’s more? They offer apple picking as well! Depending on the season, you can go watermelon, berry picking, and peach harvesting as well!
And now they have not one or two but three farms in different locations! One is in Mattituck, another in Jamesport Long Island, and the third in Riverhead. You already know that the pumpkin picking on Long Island is done at their Mattituck location, where they offer U-Pick pumpkins straight off the vines!
And no wonder such a place gets all rushed and crowded on the weekends, so it’ll be better if you plan a visit on some weekday after checking on the Facebook page of the Harbes Family Farm.
The Harbes Family Farm is located at 715 Sound Avenue Mattituck, New York City 11952.
4. Lewin Farm for U-Pick Pumpkins
Lewin Farm is one of the best choices for Pumpkin Picking Long Island, as they provide one of the finest services for U-picking.
Lewin Farm is quite a large one where you can pick your own gourds and pumpkins off the vine. They have a family-friendly pumpkin farm, but not really something else to attract the crowd other than picking your own corn maze, vegetables, and pumpkins.
If you visit the Lewin Farm, take a stop at their concession stand, where they offer roasted corn and freshly produced products from their farm!
As you get closer to the farm stand, pay attention to the signboards which lead you to the pumpkin picking long Island field. Most parking facilities will be on grass, and it’ll be better if you keep cash.
The Lewin Farm is situated at 812 Sound Ave, Calverton, New York City 11933.
5. F&W Schmitt’s Family Farm
If you live in or around Nassau County and want to save yourself from driving all the way to the far East, F&W Schmitt’s Farm is a good option as it’s close to Melville.
They have been running since 1950 and have one of the finest fields for pumpkin picking on Long Island. Their giant farm produces hundreds of Pumpkins waiting in line to go home with the pumpkin pickers.
F&W Schmitt’s Farm also gives you a bounce house or inflatables, special farm animals, corn mazes, hayrides, as well as a spooky haunted house for a great Halloween experience.
Don’t worry about food as they serve loads of it on their concession stand.
Moreover, their hayrides and entry are free with an amazing parking facility. To sum it up, they’re pretty cheap for the services they offer.
Coming a bit earlier is recommended to avoid the rush. You might want to know that they don’t allow you to pick pumpkins straight out of the vines over here.
Usually, like most of the farms, their fall Fest starts in late September, although you can keep connected through their Facebook page to get exact timings and details.
The F&W Schmitt’s Farm is located at 26 Pinelawn Road, Melville, New York 11747.
Things You Need to Know About U-Pick Pumpkin Picking Long Island Farms
There’s a lot to know about something you’ve never done before. The same is the case with the pumpkin picking off the vine. It seems simple, but of course, you can make mistakes, and to avoid them, here are few things (three to be specific) to consider –
1. First things first, you have to keep in mind that the pumping vines have tiny sharp thorns. Ensure you have good quality gloves especially meant for gardening purposes and some sheers to get the pumpkins easily off the vine without hurting yourself!
2. If you are going for Pumpkin picking Long Island, of course, it’s a fun activity, and you’d want to do everything by yourself. But in the process, you’ll get messy and dirty. After all, it’s a field job! So avoid wearing your favorite clothes or shoes, which will dishearten you after your pumpkin picking long Island session.
3. Third and the last tip is to carry your own cart or wagon or anything that has wheels so that you can carry your pumpkins efficiently, without getting tired and sweating throughout the way. Trust me, it’ll ease out everything as it’s really exhausting to hold and carry your pumpkins or gourds to your vehicle all walking.
What Time Should You Consider to Go to Pumpkin Picking Long Island?
Honestly, the best time of the year to go Pumpkin Picking Long Island usually falls between the endings of September and October months.
Although the timings can change according to the real-time weather conditions, so better if you check and confirm in advance before visiting.
Okay, so most of our pumpkin picking Long Island places are situated somewhere in the inaccessible and kind of off-the-grid areas, and what if you want to eat something? Don’t worry, I got you!
This place in Valley Stream is an amazing place that you might end up visiting every weekend! The Valbrook Diner is owned by two brothers who are great at what they started, serving delicious food!
2. King Umberto
If you are craving fried capellini in the pumpkin field, this place in Elmont is made for you, and trust me when I say they are so good! Not to forget their super amazing pizza.
If you’re the one who never had friend capellinis, it’s a very thin pasta cooked in Alfredo sauce and is fried as a patty. You gotta try this out!
3. Gonzo’s Mexican Grill
This place is the Garden City South is a really good choice for quesadillas and burritos. They have some of the best Mexican food offerings at the pumpkin picking on Long Island. You must try out if you visit and get tired from picking pumpkins!
4. A&S Bagels
The A&S located in Franklin Square is best known for its wide range of sumptuous cream cheese and bagels. You’ll find a lot of rush here on weekends, so make sure you visit on some weekday to have a good time.
Their bagels are amazing, and you should also try out their egg sandwich. Their french toast bagel and cheddar cheese are delicious as well.
Best part? A&S Bagels are open 24/7, so you can even get a late-night snack to calm down your hunger pangs or late-night cravings. Another reason why you try them out is that they’re the best bagel shops in New York, and people have actually voted for it!
So yeah, here we had five pumpkin picking Long Island farms, and we also saw some dos and don’ts along with some extra information. This article is a complete guide for your Pumpkin Picking Long Island. So don’t forget to experience pumpkin picking this coming fall!